Looking for locksmith services in Asheville? Discover the differences between lock rekeying and replacement, including costs, benefits, and when each option makes the most sense for your home or business security needs.
_______________________________

Lock Rekeying vs. Replacement in Asheville: Which is Better for Your Security?

When it comes to securing your Asheville home or business, you might be wondering whether to rekey or replace your locks. It’s a common question we hear from locals—from downtown property owners to those in North Asheville neighborhoods. The right choice depends on your specific situation, budget, and security needs. Let’s break down these options to help you make the best decision for your property.

What’s the Difference Between Lock Rekeying and Replacement?

Before jumping into costs and benefits, let’s clarify what each service actually involves.

Lock Rekeying: The Inside Scoop

When we rekey a lock, we’re essentially changing the internal pins and springs that make up the locking mechanism. This process alters the lock so it works with a new key, while the old key no longer functions. The actual lock hardware stays on your door—we just modify its inner workings.

Think of it like changing your email password. The account (lock) stays the same, but the way you access it changes completely.

Lock Replacement: Starting Fresh

Replacement is exactly what it sounds like—removing your existing lock entirely and installing a brand new one. This gives you a completely new locking system with its own unique key.

It’s like replacing your old smartphone with a newer model rather than just changing your passcode.

When to Choose Rekeying in Asheville

Rekeying makes the most sense in several common situations we see around Asheville:

When you’ve just moved into a new home or apartment in West Asheville and don’t know who might have copies of your keys. Many new Asheville residents call us for this exact reason.

If you’ve recently lost your keys somewhere between downtown and the River Arts District. Rather than worry about who might find them, rekeying provides peace of mind.

When you want all your locks (front door, back door, side entrance) to work with the same key. This key consolidation is particularly popular with rental property owners in the Asheville area.

When your locks are in good condition but you simply need to update the security access.

When Lock Replacement Is the Better Option

Sometimes, our Asheville customers are better served by complete lock replacement:

If your locks are old, worn, or damaged from Asheville’s sometimes humid climate. Many historic homes in the Montford neighborhood, for example, often benefit from updated hardware.

When you want to upgrade to a more secure lock type, such as moving from a standard deadbolt to a smart lock system—increasingly popular in newer South Asheville developments.

If you’re renovating your home and want locks that match your new door hardware or overall aesthetic.

When your current locks don’t meet your insurance requirements, which we see frequently with Asheville business owners.

Cost Comparison for Asheville Residents

Rekeying Costs

For most Asheville homes, rekeying is the more affordable option. You’re typically looking at about $15-30 per lock cylinder, plus the service call fee. Many local property managers choose this option when tenants move out of their rental properties.

The total cost for rekeying a standard Asheville home with four entry points usually ranges from $85-150, depending on lock type and complexity.

Replacement Costs

Lock replacement costs more because you’re paying for both new hardware and installation. Basic deadbolts start around $40-60 per lock, while higher-security or smart lock options can run $100-300+ each.

Including installation, most Asheville homeowners spend between $150-500 for complete lock replacement, depending on the number of doors and quality of hardware chosen.

Security Considerations for Asheville Properties

Beyond cost, security should be your primary concern. Here’s what to think about:

Rekeying won’t improve the physical security of an already weak lock. If you have basic builder-grade locks in a higher-crime area like some parts of Asheville, replacement might offer better protection.

Replacement gives you the chance to upgrade to more pick-resistant or bump-proof lock technologies, which matters for both downtown businesses and residential properties.

Some newer electronic or smart locks can’t be rekeyed in the traditional sense and would require replacement if security access needs to change.

The Convenience Factor

Rekeying typically takes less time—usually 15-30 minutes per lock for a professional Asheville locksmith. This means less disruption to your day, whether you’re at home or running a local business.

Replacement takes longer but gives you the opportunity to standardize all your locks if you currently have a mismatched set from previous owners or renovations.

Making the Right Choice for Your Asheville Property

If your current locks are in good working condition and security-grade appropriate for your neighborhood, rekeying is probably your best bet—especially if you’re simply addressing key control issues.

If your locks are showing their age or you want enhanced security features, replacement is the way to go. Many Asheville homeowners find that upgrading to newer lock technology provides both better protection and added convenience.

Get Professional Advice from Local Experts

Every property in Asheville has different security needs. The locks that work for a downtown business might not be right for a home in Biltmore Forest or a cabin in nearby Black Mountain.

A professional locksmith can assess your specific situation and recommend the best option based on your security needs, budget, and property type.

Ready to Secure Your Asheville Property?

Whether you need rekeying, replacement, or just aren’t sure which is best for your situation, our team of Asheville locksmiths is here to help. We provide fast, professional service throughout Asheville and the surrounding communities.

Don’t wait until after a security issue arises—being proactive about your lock security is always the smartest approach in our growing city.

Call us today for a free security assessment and quote on rekeying or replacement services tailored to your Asheville property’s needs. Your security is our priority, and we’re ready to help you make the right choice for your home or business.